Dyneema vs nylon tent reddit review. one night it rained .
Dyneema vs nylon tent reddit review Although both materials are artificial polymers, they have several basic differences which are crucial. A DCF tent, on average, will cost 2-3 times a sil-nylon tent of a similar configuration. Noteworthy however is that dyneema has better properties than polyester or nylon when wet - it absorbs less (maybe none) of the water and therefore doesn’t sag. It isn’t as light and low-stretch as Dyneema. I agree with this. Enjoy car camping like a car I feel like this is a pretty good article on the subject: Tent Fabric 101: Nylon vs Polyester vs Dyneema/Cuben. Or the 8lb Coleman 4-man tent with even more room. In terms of the durable material they use, the Ice pack is DCH150. Before you link me to other threads of nylon vs dyneema, please read the response I got from Dan's team below as this is not normal dyneema. I'm looking for feedback, experience, or knowledge on the floor fabrics of tents. Say that I’m taking either tent brand-new on a 7-day trip where there might be bad weather and long-lasting rain. There are so many considerations that come into play when choosing a tent that other features will weight the final decision much more heavily. MSRP: $999. You really should consider buying a better tent before spending money on a lightweight tarp. Another difference is that silpoly is lighter the morning after a wet night because it's hydrophobic. The wind changed direction in the night and the tent couldn’t handle it - a pole collapsed on me and the rest of the tent was so flappy I thought it would take off. Jun 6, 2024 · If you’re on board the Dyneema train, The X-Mid Pro design has near-universal appeal. That saves you roughly 2lbs compared to carrying either tent, neither of which serves any purpose in the wildernesses you visit. “UltraTNT is far better able to resist deformation because of the extra diagonal weave. For flys for an occasional weekend warrior, or for floors hidden from the sun, I think silnylon’s “out of the box” tear strength advantage is worth considering, but for a frequent backpacker the much faster UV degradation of nylon seems to give the edge to poly. Usually around 16-20mm wide, nylon climbing slings are much bulkier (and more durable) than lightweight 6-14mm Dyneema slings. 6 How much benefit is there with dyneema other than weight? Is it worth the extra cost? How waterproof is 40D Nylon 6. 40D is a very thin, almost translucent ripstop. The most common comparo is 1. Jan 6, 2023 · For years, Dyneema Composite Fabrics (DCFs) and Hybrids (DCHs) have been the go-to choice of ultralight backpack, shelter and accessory makers — and, for good reason. People purchasing a premium tent like the X-Mid Pro 2 should have read the specifications and the price is clearly marked. Gridstop nylon AKA Dyneema X - This is a standard ripstop nylon (typically 210D) that has UHMWPE* fibers woven into the fabric in a grid pattern. Best Nylon Tents: Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2: Known for its lightweight and durability, ideal trail tent for backpackers. Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL2 Tent. 3000mm any difference for those first 7 days of use? I’m taking a look at that article, thanks for sharing! Btw. Pro-con: It's very light (~115g iirc). While polyester doesn't seem to sag, but the trade off is weight and strength. This makes them the best choice for situations such as extending a belay device, replacing anchor webbing or attaching yourself to an anchor before abseiling. Backpacking tents are generally made of one of three materials: coated nylon, coated polyester, or Dyneema composite fabric (DCF). DCF (Dyneema Composite Fabric) has since grown in popularity. It's tough to justify paying almost 3 times as much for a tarp but here I am, looking for that justification (or not. Big Agnes Tiger Wall Platinum 2 Tent. I experienced several mild rain events while using this tent, two consecutive days of near-constant rain or drizzle while at a basecamp, three mild-to-moderate thunderstorms, and one severe thunderstorm with approximately 10-minutes of marble-sized hail and gusty winds of around 15-20 mph. DCF stuff sacks come apart in a horrible mess of fibers and threads hanging everywhere. Reddit outpost of the much more active Durston Gearheads group on Facebook; for owners and fans of ultralight Durston Gear products like the X-Mid tents, Kakwa backpacks, and Z-Flick adjustable-length tent poles. These lightweight yet super strong and highly water-resistant materials tick important boxes for outdoor enthusiasts looking to keep their pack weight low. Personally I like Dyneema webbing for load bearing purposes but it is $$$ and available in limited widths so you can’t use it with all components. I never feel tent envy when I'm using it. Regular old nylon packs are tougher for the weight. most do. This is the material that DCF shelters such as the Zpacks Duplex Tent are I'm looking for feedback, experience, or knowledge on the floor fabrics of tents. May 6, 2025 · Paul “Pie” Ingram is a thru-hiker based in Helsinki, Finland, and has checked off the AT, Annapurna Circuit, CDT, and more than 400 miles of the High Sierra Trail. I learned years ago the airline personnel always roll their clothes when packing, and I discovered this hold true to me for tents, sleeping bags, and sleeping pads as well. Firstly Dyneema is much lighter when compared to nylon for tents of similar strength. Effective vapor barrier. Thread count is like your bedsheets, the number of threads per inch of fabric. 2oz/yd or 1oz per shelter heavier, but with a lifespan at least double (ask MLD who offer their shelters in both). Nylon for anchors and tethers. Fix the leaky tent by getting a better tent. Feb 20, 2023 · What is Dyneema Composite Fabric (DCF)? Dyneema Composite Fabric or DCF, previously known as Cuben Fiber, is a laminate fabric consisting of crisscrossing strands of Dyneema or ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene (UHMWPE), sandwiched between thin polyester films. For those interested there's an interesting test done and documented by DMM comparing the strength of Dyneema vs. Hilleberg, Fjällräven, Helsport, North Face or other expedition class tent makers don't seem to have any Dyneema fabric tents, some of them do have it in their guylines. A kind of consensus in climbing seems to be that it's generally ok to use Dyneema as long as you know what its limitations are and use it accordingly. Borrowing an innovative fabric from sailboat racing, hikers were suddenly able to cut their tent weight by 50 percent overnight. Condensation is a consideration in any tent. I'll probably try to sell it and I'll likely never have a sil nylon tarp again. I imagine the same thing would happen between high(er) elasticity, lower strength nylon versus low stretch, high strength dyneema. I guess the stretch is useful when it is put under a sudden load, like when the parachute opens. Polyester is for all other purposes or if I’m trying to cut costs. That's a waterproof dyneema interior, which is very thin like you would use for an ultralight tent, laminated to regular old 150 denier polyester on the exterior. I replaced the sacks that came with my tents with proper silnylon sacks, slightly larger in size so they weren't such a pain in the ass to put the tent back in. Does 1200mm vs. I think substituting DCF in place of nylon in a normal double wall tent, especially without adjusting the design to minimize abrasion on the fly fabric, is asking for trouble. Help with choosing a large and comfortable tent for leisurely hikes with a girl in the company of friends. Generally, I’m ok with either. It sits right in the middle of the cost range of single-wall DCF tents, but with some seriously thoughtful design and a high standard of construction. I've seen the newer ones and they look great, too. When it does so, the stronger, less elastic steel cable would take basically the entire weight. Floor holes in tents arent usually anything too concerning. That could be a very long time. one night it rained Rather than serving as a buying guide, this article is intended to provide users a very basic level of understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of the most common fabrics used in tent and tarp design: nylon, polyester, and DCF (Dyneema Composite Fabric, formerly known as Cuben Fiber). -my dyneema tent developed pinholes around the apexes and other areas after 2 years of use, weeping water into the tent. It’s now used This year i taped up one middle puncture spot and reinforced all 4 corners also with tape. Feb 9, 2021 · Read our review of the DCF Two. MSRP: $549. Hello. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. So if people feel the tent is overpriced compared to competitors since it has a nylon floor, then they shouldn't purchase it. When I get the extra money (hahaha) I would 100% look in to doing some MYOG work and buying some Dyneema to sew on to or to completely replace the tent floor. weight, water absorption means that any strength advantage nylon has in dry conditions can disappear in wet/stormy conditions (where you most need that strength) because it gives up 10% strength while potentially doubling in weight. 6 vs Dyneema as a bed during rain? I know condensation is an issue with the zpack. I used a Gossamer Gear One in 2008 back when they were made of Spinnaker fabric and I still use it. Big Agnes Tiger Wall 2 Carbon Tent. "Dyneema Grid" A Nylon ripstop fabric where the ripstop is made of Dyneema fibers. It's also important to note that nylon denier does not directly map to wind or water resistance. Nylon is the stronger material that can make a pretty tough tent at 15D, but the trade off is that it absorbs water and sags. If you use shelters like most backpackers do - set up in early evening when you make camp for the day and take down in the morning when you start hiking again, UV damage is a non-issue. At a time when 20-plus-pound base weights had been common, 15- and even 10-pound base weights suddenly became widely attainable. The weight goes down from here. I then bought a DCF Duomid used (camo version, it was awesome) and it shed the sea wind like a champ on an exposed section of the SWCP in England. Pick the tent you like the best. I've only been slacking since last Sunday, and only had to buy webbing because I already had the rest of the gear from climbing. Tent Fabric 101: Nylon vs Polyester vs Dyneema/Cuben. If you are adamantly anti-dyneema, I'd like to hear that as well). With Silpoly (or nylon) I can stuff my Tarp and Bivy in my pack (no stuff sack) around other odd shaped objects, and it packs down significantly smaller. With this tent it does not matter if it rains, i just set up, jump in, meditate, read and hang around. It's a great tent and has always been a great tent. For car camping, you'll want privacy. Argali is cheaper and has 20D Nano-Ripstop SilPoly for its outer layer and the insert has 40D Nylon 6. Also, I am chosing to invest alot of time and concentration to make a tent, so that is another considerable cost. You lose the bug net and floor (but can add them in for 200 grams or so with an inner, or pack an UL bivvy for versatility) and gain a much more durable (and stealthy) tent that packs smaller and costs less. The only reason I’m in this never-ending tent hunt is because Tarptent is not available in Europe :( Some don't fold and roll their dyneema. 95 Weight: 22 ounces Material: DCF fly, nylon tent body Type: Semi-freestanding. They seem to cut more easily but resist punctures and tears better. slingfin Springbar fake reviews. I think it squeezes out more air, and you don't have the fold taking up room. I own and use a dyneema tent and some tarps and ground clothes. Jun 8, 2023 · “A Dyneema tent used in the field for multiple days will never again set up as well as it did the first time,” says Henry Shires, founder of ultralight shelter brand Tarptent. Nylon is the most common, but polyester or DCF are better choices for your ultralight tent. I want to pack up and hike, not wait around for my tarp to dry so I'm not carrying a bunch of water. Undebatable that a DCF floor is significantly more expensive than nylon floor. That alone makes it a better tent material. So now I'm considering two options: Nemo Dagger If I could get a copper spur with a dyneema fly and carbon poles… that would be my ideal bikepacking tent. The other tent is my friend Porter’s Mountain Laurel Designs Solomid XL made of 30 denier silnylon. Mar 6, 2022 · Nylon or polyester have some give to them, so there isn’t as much strain on zippers and therefore sliders don’t wear out as quickly. MSRP: $449. But OSMO is much quieter Lightweight tents are an extremely niche product, and if my tent blows while I'm off the beaten path, I'll probably have to deal with it till I get home. Dec 2, 2022 · Is Dyneema or nylon better for tents? Dyneema is better for tents compared to nylon. Also nylon will lose strength as well as fade with UV exposure (probably not significant unless you leave your tent up during the day, but I don't really know). While there are other lightweight, waterproof tents in a similar weight range, they just don't perform as well as this one. At one point HMG was making woven Dyneema (utra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene) packs which are incredibly durable. The tent is not reliable - don't fix that problem with a tarp. I have several ultralight tents, but in this case I want more comfort I recently bought a Nemo Dragonfly bikepack and it's a great tent, but it's still a bit cramped. I would say durability is a notch below sylnylon but unlikely to be a problem for most. Key differences among tents is double wall or single wall - double wall helps you avoid brushing yourself or your gear against a wet surface. I've been using the… Jan 10, 2020 · Favorite Poly/Nylon Combo Tent (1 to 3 person) MSR Elixir – Although most tents these days are made from nylon, there are a few that use a combination of the two fabrics. An ultra 200 fabric tent? (Ultra is 70 PE/30 poly with laminate, being used for new backpacks) Virgin uhmwpe fleece, inherently waterproof, would pair well with silpoly poncho or by itself, great for socks Is there a way to overcome the slippery less of virgin material in fine denier to make rain jackets, down Jacket shells, tents etc Especially with a 'mid-style tent. Ingram’s favorite tent is Dec 6, 2023 · With a clever combination of Dyneema and Nanovent 3-layer fabrics, not to mention a suspended Dyneema rooftop design with vents, we now have a truly waterproof and well-ventilated single-wall 4-season tent. MSR Hubba Hubba NX: Many camping tent reviews say this tent offers excellent weather resistance and ventilation. Plus you can enjoy seeing the stars at night. So does spinnaker. Dan Durston elaborates more on this nylon vs silpoly on his website: “Focusing on strength vs. Oct 19, 2024 · A DCF tent is built using Dyneema Composite Fabrics, a specialty material that requires specialty machinery to assemble, making it very expensive and not widely used by larger companies but more by cottage companies. Or not - tarps are fun . He bought this tent in the Spring of 2017 and has used it for around 150 nights. 2oz (30D) nylon as we have here, where the nylon is about 0. Nylon weaves are water-permeable unless treated or layered with other fabrics (most 1000d backpacks have an additional waterproof liner) Heavy denier nylon is chosen for durability, not weather-resistance. Get a 6lb $100 Coleman dome tent with lots of room. I bought a Warbonnet sil nylon tarp because they didn't have the silpoly. Oct 19, 2024 · Most tent manufacturers are going to work hard to align the denier, thread count, alongside performance into their gear builds. 0oz DCF versus 1. It's like putting a bandaid on a gunshot wound. The NF tent is a polyester since which performs better in that respect but polyester is a weaker fabric in the same denier and hasn't been available in thin derniers until recently because of thatnot sure what specifically improved to allow it. For a given weight, nylon or poly provide at least as much floor durability as DCF - I would argue they are better. Most tents are not waterproof in torrential rains and winds This is false. The jab was directed towards companies charging $1000+ for DCF versions of their normal nylon tents (that still weigh more than even a silnylon flat tarp) without making See full list on outlifeexpert. Silpoly v Silnylon isn't the issue, it's the dyneema sitting off to the side for an extra $200. My tents are zpacks and my tarps are a mix. Some of the places I used to camp, there isn't a whole lot of choice but to camp on top of granite that only has a small amount of soil on it. ” With canvas tents, rolling is always more compact than folding. Mar 1, 2023 · DCF was the revolutionary backpacking fabric of the 2000s. The nylon would stretch quickly under the tents tension forces and the dyneema would take all the load. The Dyneema fibers do not accept dye giving this fabric is distinctive grid look. Used a nylon tent during most of that time and it did get a couple very minor floor holes (easily taped) during that time. Additionally, Dyneema does not absorb any moisture and is waterproof. IMO dyneema is half the weight for about 3x price. On a recent trip to Iceland a partner had a 2p mid from hyperlight mountain gear with the internal net and floor insert. So a 310T tent fabric would contain 310 threads per inch of usable fabric, the higher this number the more threads within that inch exists. But yeah, I think it became popular because the military etc had access to it and a lot of survival authors and trainers were ex military back in the 1980's when paracord and Ferro rods and little survival kits in tins really took off in the civilian world. com 3 days ago · Ease of Cleaning: Nylon tents are relatively easy to clean but require gentle handling to avoid damage. 95 Weight: 43 ounces Material: Nylon Type: Freestanding. It comes with a 70D taffeta nylon floor that is hydrostatically rated to 3,000 mm, and a footprint for underneath to protect the tent floor. Quoting Dan Durston, an experienced hiker and tent designer, on the choice between nylon and polyester: The sagging is why you can't make large tents with nylon but it is manageable in a small tent. This usually comes in 210d but Gossamer Gear used to have a 140d version that I have seen a few other places. Polyamide is nylon and often a bit lighter but I hear the UV resistance is considerably less. 85oz/sqyd. Hence the name. Oct 24, 2015 · I have mentioned this before. IMO the difference in UV resistance between silnylon and silpoly is vastly overstated (usually by people selling silpoly shelters). Mar 25, 2024 · NEMO Mayfly OSMO 2P Tent Review The Mayfly’s OSMO Rainfly is a mix of 15D nylon and 30D and abrasion resistance. IE. Nothing wrong with the design or fit and finish, the fabric was just terrible. Dyneema for extendable draws and extra long runners for gear anchors. Nylon slings. The trade off with UHMWPE is that it is much stronger per weight, but weaker under shock load. I think it is the right tent for probably 90 percent of long-distance hikers, assuming you use trekking poles. I actually bought it two weeks ago and have camped 5 times ! since ! IT MAKES IT SO EASY ! condensation isn't bad, functionality is great loads of handy pockets and stuff completley waterproof on the bottom and the top. It's stronger, lighter, doesn't retain water, doesn't stretch and is waterproof but it is pretty expensive, but their tents are already expensive and people are willing to Dyneema composite fabric is 2 layers of plastic film with some Dyneema fibers laminated in between to reinforce it. So asking if Dyneema is durable, and then referencing HMG packs doesn't make any sense. It has a lot of space for a one person tent. Specifically the nylon VS Dyneema flooring of the Durston xmid pro 2+. Jun 13, 2023 · When bringing packrafts to a mountain lake, I was grateful for the light weight of the X-Mid Pro. A Liteway Pyraomm mid tarp is (after seam sealing) the same weight as a Zpacks Plex solo. 95 Weight: 31 ounces Material I also think the number of cottage companies moving from silnylon to silpoly is pretty discouraging for silnylon’s future. 210D nylon is much thicker, and it's a common denier, around 4. r/Ultralight is the largest online Ultralight Backcountry Backpacking community! This sub is about overnight backcountry backpacking, with a focus on moving efficiently, packing light, generally aiming at a sub 10 pound base weight, and following LNT principles. dzqtx inim fem ifxtm teldi cmmcby lcrc orid kdncd cnr